| Date | Time | Headline |
|---|
| Wed Sep 4 | 18:32 | Clay Holmes Losing Grip On Ninth Inning Duties |
| Sat Aug 24 | 00:41 | Clay Holmes Secures Save Friday |
| Tue Aug 20 | 18:28 | Clay Holmes Likely To Remain Closer |
| Mon Aug 12 | 19:30 | Clay Holmes Unavailable On Monday |
| Wed Jul 31 | 18:32 | Clay Holmes Tosses Scoreless Ninth Inning For The Save |
| Mon Jul 15 | 12:39 | Clay Holmes Hit With Blown Save, Loss Against Orioles |
| Fri Jun 7 | 09:21 | Clay Holmes Picks Up 18th Save |
| Mon May 20 | 23:38 | Clay Holmes Blows First Save of Season, Allows Four Runs |
| Sat May 4 | 18:55 | Clay Holmes Earns 11th Save Saturday Afternoon |
| Thu Apr 18 | 11:31 | Clay Holmes Records Seventh Save Wednesday |
| Sat Apr 13 | 17:05 | Clay Holmes Posts Sixth Save |
| Wed Apr 10 | 00:30 | Clay Holmes Notches Fifth Save Of Season Tuesday |
| Mon Apr 1 | 00:50 | Clay Holmes Knocks Down Third Save |
| Sat Mar 30 | 23:24 | Clay Holmes Records Second Save In 2024 |
| Thu Mar 28 | 21:41 | Clay Holmes Hangs On For First Save |
| Thu Mar 14 | 16:58 | Clay Holmes Still The Yankees' Closer |
| Thu Jan 11 | 22:47 | Clay Holmes And Yankees Settle At $6 Million |
| Tue Sep 26 2023 | 00:33 | Clay Holmes Earns 22nd Save Of Season Monday |
| Thu Sep 7 2023 | 08:11 | Clay Holmes Earns Save No. 18 |
| Mon Aug 21 2023 | 00:22 | Clay Holmes Takes Fourth Loss Sunday |